Tuesday, 9 April 2019

SPRING 2019

                                                           

Another season has begun and it's going to be another busy year. You will have received an e mail some months ago now about events and can also find them listed on the 45end website.
Sadly what was  looking to be the big continental trip of the year to Eggmühl in Bavaria has been cancelled due to the area of the battle/camp apparently being part of a wildlife/bird sanctuary.
this cancellation meant that Ligny became a feasible event in its stead and a new show on the Horizon is Hoogstraten/Wuustwezel which is likely to be at the end of September, 27-29th. An event there in 2014 was very well put together and fondly remembered by those who went. The cancellation also meant the rather 1809/Bavarian theme I had started for this newsletter became less relevant but hey ho, I hope you can still enjoy it with a weissbier from Tescos.

For those interested in Almelo in May there is more information here:
https://www.historischfestivalalmelo.nl




You have probably heard that one of our long time members, Patrick McGillon, usually known as Pat, passed away this January gone, it seems to have been quite a quick passing and I remember Pat still fighting at the barricades at Holepark in 2017.



                                                        ----------------------------------

                                                  The AGM and 45eme party night.

The annual AGM has been and gone, as mentioned, as usual once the details of the year gone by been assessed and required actions and a plan for 2019 put forward it was time for the dinner and party games, as colourful as ever.


Surely a scene from a Paris salon?

The minister of war made an appearance. 

What is meat pie in French? 


What happens in Newbury stays in Newbury.

-------------

                   The Bavarian army in the Napoleonic wars.
                               
Bavaria was one of the largest contributors of troops to the confederation of the Rhine yet it is morep appropriate to regard them as an allied nation in as much as they could provide a whole field army with supports and not merely a couple of regiments as was the case with smaller territories.  The average troops are often compared unfavourably with the French, is this a fair evaluation?
Like the British opinions of the Dutch-Belgians in the Waterloo campaign much has been coloured in discussion by the fact French accounts often looked down upon them and many French certainly thought themselves the better troops and as with the former comparison if something goes awry for a French commander, blame someone else!

During the revolutionary period the army was certainly in a poor state, the soldiery were drawn from the lowest social circles, including criminals, and poorly equipped, often short of shoes and with cavalry regiments with dismounted men due to a lack of horses. Morale was never going to be high. Officers bought commissions and seldom had any experience and were often on leave for months at a time.


However in 1801 Benjamin Rumford, an American by birth, was employed to bring in reforms (he deserves an article himself for many accomplishments including inventing the coffee percolator and running soup kitchens in France late in the wars with his own soup recipe designed to give people a fully nutritional meal).
The unpopular white uniform was done away with and replaced with a cornflower blue coat and raupenhelm, the distinctive tall crested helmet..
This headwear was not so popular being heavy and unbalanced especially when rain soaked the crest. skirmish tactics were introduced and drill with smaller columns of men made for more maneuverability. A limited conscription was introduced and buying commissions banned. The army began to represent the whole of society and its officers required merit to get ahead.




What shade of blue the uniform was is still debated, the light ''cornflower' blue of the national flag is often thought to be the colour but surviving uniforms are a darker blue than those most commonly seen in illustrations, reenactment or on the wargames table. (there is even a theory that in the 1970s Airfix only produced a dark blue and a light blue paint and so to differentiate from French coats this very light blue was used by early wargamers to paint Bavarians and it has stuck!). Bavarian uniforms later in the century did become a very light blue, which may have added to the confusion.

Two examples of surviving uniform coats. Part of the collection of the army Museum in Ingolstadt.

Napoleon alluded to the animosity between Bavarians and Austrians in his speech before Abensburg (see below), according to 'For God and for Kaiser' the hussars at Austerlitz charged the French 106eme with abandon because they were mistaken for 'The hated Bavarians'.
Bavaria joined in the Austerlitz campaign as one of the first German states to side with Napoleonic France, alongside Baden and Wurtemburg. This may have been partly provoked by Austrian General Mack marching a large army into the then neatral Bavaria without so much as a by your leave. King Maximilian could only shrug and moved the army conveniently out of the way until he could opening declare with France.

What's all this about looting or ill treating the locals? Both of these accusations have fallen on the Bavarians. In the 1809 campaign a village was looted and set on fire but the brigade had not received rations for three days so where is the difference between searching for food and 'living off the land' that the French habitually did? Nor is there any reason to suspect the fire was anything other than an accident and may not have been remembered at all except for the anecdotal story that the crown prince was asleep upstairs in a house and had to be hurriedly evacuated.
Wargames foundry: Bavarians' looting! lock up your chickens.

The reputation may have been further enforceed by Bavarian troops in the Tyrol facing guerillas often as merciless in their ambushes and treatment of unlucky captives as those in Spain and with a similar cycle of vengeance, but again this behaviour was no different to that of the French. That said it was held at the time that civilians would rather have four Frenchmen billeted on them than one German! 


So were they 'good' soldiers? Overall I believe yes, the early reforms and organisational experience of the 1805 campaign put them in good shape and the officer class saw themselves as professionals, the men ready to obey them. The early years of the alliance saw the nation prosper and wars were in the national interest, especially when others had marched into their own territory as in 1809, the appearance of Napoleon always caused cheers and a clamour to see the great man. The jagers (light infantry) and Chevaux-Legere (Light dragoons) were considered very fine troops and accounts often give them particular mention. 

1809 was the peak of their proficiency. Fighting alone they saw many successes and incidents of valour and  when the day turned against them they usually retreated in good order.
It is beyond the scope of this article to describe all these engagements but I will give Napoleon's speech before a series of  clashes that would become known as the battle of Abensburg on the 20th.

"Bavarian soldiers! I stand before you not as the Emperor of France but as the protector of your country and the Rhinebund. Bavarians! Today you fight alone against the Austrians. Not a single Frenchmen is in the front line, they are in reserve and the enemy is unaware of their presence. I have complete faith in your bravery. I have already expanded the borders of your land; I see now that I have not yet gone far enough. I will make you so great that you will not need my protection in any future war with Austria. For 200 years, the Bavarian flag, supported by France, has fought heroically against Austria. We will march to Vienna where we will punish it for all the evil it has caused your fatherland. They want to divide your nation and enroll you in Austrian regiments! Bavarians! This war will be the last you will fight against your enemies. Attack them with the bayonet and destroy them!' 



Having ridden hard he had outpaced the guard and spent the night bivouacked with the Bavarians, which I believe reflects his faith in them as a reliable force.

Morale however fell in the Russian campaign, and desertion and even suicide marked the advance, men were described as having 'died of homesickness' in the dreary wastes. The losses of most of the Bavarian division shook the nation and calls to end the alliance sounded loud, this was not just heard in Bavaria for 1813 saw a growing sense that the German nations, if they came together, could form a significant power and no longer be overshadowed as mere pawns to France or Austria. 

Having quit the alliance a Bavarian army under Wrede (baulstered by Austrian elements) tried to block Napoleon's retreat from Leipzig back to the Rhine but Wrede assumed the French would be more disorganised and strung out than they proved to be and the veteran French forces pushed through after a determined assault, despite severe loses especially where a division was pushed back onto a river with only a single bridge, the Bavarians did not break and retired in largely good order. This battle probably saved Bavaria from being punished for its former long association with France. 


Fur Bayern und Konig Max!

------------------
The battle of little big Arapile.

Sunday 13th January saw a re-fights of the battle of Salamanca,  Los Arapiles to the French. With about four divisions each it was going to be a full day of action. Generals Irwin, Bradshaw and Timm (British/allied) vs Bentley, Stearman and Ricketts (Roy advised by ADC Groves as a wargames newbie).

The Boss.

Both sides had a general plan discussed in the privacy of the staff room, would they survive contact with the enemy? Certainly not for the French, the dice Gods never backed up their plans and the battle ground to a halt in the centre and then began to be pushed back towards the French side. 

The calm before the storm, the greater Arapiles' in the centre. French forces can be seen on this flank, the British heavy cavalry similarly came on the left flank and would meet their opposite number.

Heavy dragoons Vs Curassiers! 


The French column that marched right round to the British rear/flank.. only to find the battle all but lost. Oh well, they lived to fight another day. Demi turn adroite! March! 

None of our commanders were taken out of action as quickly as Massena was by a shell on the actual day. 
The village was taken quickly and kept the British at a respectful distance for quite a while. 


The chaos of battle. The final stages made a great example of desperate, disjointed defences amid the growing panic as shrinking French forces became islands of defence each concerned with only their own situation/survival and the Generals pondering when it would be an honourable moment to march away and save what was left of their own division.

Next time!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ickworth

The much anticipated first field event of the year and a good turn out for the 45eme and the French brigade with a boost to our light troops in the form of the 2eme Legere. 
Saturday saw forces split between the battle besides the house and a running skirmish with several objectives away in the woods and paths of the grounds. This was a test run for a possible campaign event at Ickworth and everyone seemed to enjoy it.


The British spoke highly of our performance as a brigade in both activities. The rifles saying it felt like we were 'everywhere' and confounded an attack from the rear on one flank by simply closing in around them in a pivot that caught them in a noose, the hunter becoming the hunted.
 The battle on the Sunday had an atmospheric haze of low lying smoke due to the wet weather although the rain had stopped for the battle. It was a dynamic fight that was quite a spectacle with two wings and skirmishers and an opening cavalry attack on the poor Sappeurs after stirling work of shooting the bag Piper.


t
skirmish squad ready to go

Tony's medical display and engagement with the public went down very well so it was fortunate he escaped the firing squad at impressive speed at the close of the battle. 



The catering corp also received much praise and at one point had four people holding a blanket over the fire to try and get it/keep it going to get lunch on in the rain. A variety of weather makes for an interesting season.



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Meine guter Kamerade.

The song 'Meine guter Kamerad' has become the tradition lament for fallen soldiers in Germany, you will often find it associated with the two world wars but it is a non political or religious song and so has remained relevant, in fact it is a truly Napoleonic song from its inception and descriptive theme.



Written first as a poem in 1809 by Ludwig Urland, a poet from Württemberg and supposedly dedicated to some Baden soldiers who fell in the Tyrolean insurrection, in 1820 it was set to the music of a Swiss folk song. It is also sung by the French foreign legion and the only song they must salute that is not a national anthem.

The words recount a soldier marching and then fighting in line, standing and loaded as his friend beside him is hit and falls at his feet, the first soldier laments that he cannot help his comrade because the line is loading and firing their muskets, his duty must come before giving comfort and the man dies before him.

Ich hatt' einen Kameraden,                             
Einen bessern findst du nit.                           
Die Trommel schlug zum Streite,                   
Er ging an meiner Seite                                   
In gleichem Schritt und Tritt.       
In gleichem Schritt und Tritt.
                     
Der Kugel kam geflogen:
Gilt’s mir oder gilt es dir?
Ihn hat es weggerissen,
Er liegt zu meinen Füßen
Als wär's ein Stück von mir.
Als wär's ein stück von mir.

Will mir die Hand noch reichen,
Derweil ich eben lad.
Kann dir die Hand nicht geben,
Bleib du im ew'gen Leben
Mein guter Kamerad!
Mein guter Kamerad!



(Translation)

I had a comrade,
No better could you find,
The drum called us to battle,
He marched right by my side,
In matching pace and step,
In matching pace and step.

The ball it came flying,
Is it for me or is it for you?
He was then torn away,
He fell down at my feet
Just like a piece of me,
Just like a piece of me.

His hand it reaches out to me
As I am to reload
I cannot hold onto your hand
You rest in eternal life
My good comrade
My good comrade.

There are some later versions of the song with additions/variations but this is the original except it is sometimes written with either 'A ball.' Or ' The ball..' the latter supposed to suggest that it was fated that his comrade should die, the bullet with his name on it.

Mein guter kameraden!                   


                                        -----------------------------------------------------------------
                                                        Rogues Gallery



             The Timms at the NA social gathering in Bury St Edmunds.

                                                   An aide de camp and an aid de field.

Worcester. Lawrence is turned away by the White beards. Come back in a few years young man! 

Serge enthralls his audience.



Duncan leading the regiment over the bridge at Hole park.


Next newsletter will be August. As usual feel free to send any news, reviews, articles, etc. Thanks to the usual suspects whose FB pictures have been used. En Avant!


Saturday, 3 November 2018

Autumn 2018

                                                          
..and so the last engagements of the gallant 45e for this season have passed. It's been a great year for the regiment with two international excursions and major UK events at Spetchly and Hole park that saw the French brigade doing toe to toe with the Brits. It's also been a good year for recruitment with half a dozen new faces who are fast becoming excellent Soldats and Cantineres.

                             
Already there are rumblings of great things for 2019, some of the usual fixtures such as the two above being likely, and also a trip to Bavaria for Eggmuhl to a march besides our German allies verses the Kaiserliks! Although I hear the French look set to outnumber all other nations in the field.


By the time of the spring newsletter the AGM/party on the 26th January at the Chequers hotel, Newbury, will have come and gone and a much clearer picture of events settling into place.
 Our courageous comrades in the 21e will be joining the occasion as well as a number of the Sappeurs.  Be sure to book early if you wish to go and mention the 45e if getting accommodation at the Chequers hotel as there is usually reduced rate.   
                                    


Also for the calendar is March 16 when the Napoleonic association is holding its social get together in Bury St Edmunds, at the Athenaeum assembly rooms. Tickets are £35 for members and £50 for non, including two course meal and dancing. From Kate lobb at kate.davis1.kd@gmail.com

                               -------------------------------


                             Dover Western Heights.
A regular fixture of the 45eme year are the twice yearly open days at Dover western heights, a good time is usually guaranteed but in September so often is the rain.
                                   
Prepare for action!  down in the lower casements the unwitting British do not know what is coming for them. The gallant French would steal forth and drive back the redcoats to the upper level where after an unremitting skirmish they would see their colours captured and the tricolor flying over the ramparts.

Food and lots of predominantly German bear at Cullin's yard, where lots of great ideas were put forward, like invading Russia.
After some drill displays to the hardy onlookers the skirmish was on again with quite a few shots got off given the weather.
packing up after the last event of the season is always a bitter sweet occasion, no more action for five months, au revoir mon Amis!




---------------------------------------------------------------


The army of the Kingdom of Italy!


For most of the Napoleonic epoch a significant contribution to 'France's' armies were troops drawn from north and central Italy.
The people of these territories often saw Napoleon as the liberator of their lands from being another Austro-Hungarian province but like other such territories taxation and the demand for conscripts meant that particular novelty soon wore off. The code Napoleon and post-revolutionary ideas like universal education would have a long lasting effect on 'Italy'.


The Italians are often overlooked. I believe this is  because they are often regarded as 'Frenchmen in white' by writers, historians and wargamers, this is perhaps understandable as they were equipped, uniformed and trained in the same style as their gallic breathren. The King of Italy was also Napoleon himself although most of the day to day work of the head of state was left to Eugene De Beauharnais, the viceroy, although Napoleon's shadow was caste over any significant decisions. This direct control meant there was no intercession or questioning of orders or organisation or conscription as with allied States, at least not from any authority.


Two major battles will always be held up as 'Italian victories' that of Raab in 1809 and Maloyarlslavets in 1812.

Raab was fought on the 14th of June, 1809, in what is now Gyor in Hungary, with Franco-Italian forces under Eugene De Beauharnais versus the Austro-hungarians under the Archduke John.
The initial fighting revolved around a farmhouse that changed hands five times until a powerful Austrian force seemed to envelope it. Meanwhile Austrian guns covering a river crossing were knocked out by a larger French battery and Grouchy's cavalry crossed over and after crossing swords with the hussars on the far side were in a position to outflank the Austrians.

Eugene now ordered in an attack lead by the Italian royal guards and they recaptured the farmhouse after fierce fighting. The Archduke John ordered a general retreat, there would be no advance.  The main consequence of the victory was that reinforcements could no longer reach the Archduke Charles embattled at Wagram and this knowledge weighed heavily in giving him course to call for an armistice.

When Napoleon evacuated Moscow Eugene and his Italian forces were given the task of leading the march towards Kaluga. When Cossacks reported these troops on the march Kutusov believed them to be only a large foraging party and sent General Dokhturov to engage them. The Russian entered the town to find the bridge already under Italian control, a large Russian attack took all the town but could not take the bridgehead and a counter attack by the 15th Italian division under Pino drove the green coats from the streets (many were also actually green being young soldiers called up to replace the horrendous loses of Borodino). Night fell and Napoleon received news of the victory, however he knew this was not the main Russian army as Kutusov was now astride the road and could have forced a battle next day but Napoleon did not believe a way could be forced through to the Kaluga road and so made the fateful decision to turn back onto the devastated road they had advanced upon.

Both of these actions had key points of showing the Italians were keen soldiers, not hesitating to launch assaults and partake in street fighting and certainly not second tier troops.




In 1813, having commanded the survivors of the Grande armee, Eugene was ordered back to Italy to prepare the country for war against the Austrians in 1814. He tried to have himself crowned King in the wake of his step-fathers abdication but the senate could not come to an agreement and riots in Milan called for an end to the regime. on April 28th Eugene surrendered to the Austrians and was exiled to Bavaria where he remained for the rest of his life. The geographical area we call Italy returned to its pre-Napoleonic state of petty kingdoms and holy seats but these regimes would see there days numbered in the new century.



----------------------------------------------------
Hole Park!

Hole park in deepest Kent was again a big event for the Napoleonic association and saw a good turn out from the 45eme, 21eme and the Sappeurs in attendence, fine weather and a successful event although after three attempts to capture Kent it seems Napoleon was thwarted again.. but we all know this was just a feint and London was captured three days later.



Form up and prepare to march!


The cantineres and camp followers, Always there for moral and practical support and occasionally to shoot redcoats in the face.


The duel! two honourable men *cough* seek satisfaction.


-------------------------------------------------

Hat news!

As you probably know our very own Serge Dubonnet (Stuart) has been promoted to unit Eagle bearer whenever it takes the field, congratulations!

As part of his new role he has purchased a new shako from the excellent GBL shakos. apparently a conversation had gone;
'You wont need all the braid and bling on the shako.
'Okay.'

'Hello, GBL shakos? yeah, I will need all the braid and bling on the shako. Cheers.'





Serge's new shako is so smart that questions have been raised about which of the two will be in charge.


In other hat news our very own Plinny is planning on making a colourful appearance as a mamluk, (most often seen written as mameluke/s in Napoleonic literature/studies) but so far all we have is the teaser of his turban.


---------------------------------------------
Marshal Ney; reappraised.
Many moons ago when I went on an access to higher education course at Brighton college we were all required to do a five minute presentation in front of the class and I chose for my subject Marshal Ney; the bravest of the brave. My knowledge of Napoleonic history was not extensive but I'd seen Waterloo and got a book out of the library. He was clearly a hero!



Young Ney as a hussar, his ideas on warfare were initially quite conventional even as he rose through the ranks in the army of the Rhine he believed a battle was a set piece contest, the loser retired and the winner slept on the field of glory, however he was shaken up by the new ways of Napoleonic warfare and as a professional adapted. His friendship with the famous Swiss tactician Jomini is well documented. 


In the last few years however I find myself sometimes scoffing when Ney is mentioned, he certainly had his qualities and was a true trooper but (French) history may have been better served if he had never been promoted above general.


What was going through Ney's mind during those heady days in Belgium?

 He had been one of the Marshal's to push for Napoleon's abdication in 1814, then served King Louis, famously confronted then joined Napoleon on his return..

 He must have suspected if the Emporers gamble failed he would be called a traitor to the King, maybe the old Ney would have thought of it as conquer or die situation, or maybe his sluggishness at Quatre Bra was a lack of commitment or giddiness at the pace of events, like he was riding a horse he could barely control.

Ney is mainly criticised in the campaign for two things, not attacking sooner at Quatre Bras and launching the cavalry charges unsupported on the allied squares and wasting the superior French cavalry.
The two actions are almost contradictory, one lethargic and non committal and the other fiery and impulsive. There is a theory that we today would recognise Ney as suffering from post traumatic stress disorder after the Russian campaign and his actions since then were certainly more erratic, like the seeker of glory had seen too much.
However it has been put forward that it was Soult whom was to blame for Ney's tardiness in attacking, as Napoleon's chief of staff he never informed Ney of the fact the Emporer was NOT coming to crush the British but was looking east, not west, to deal with the Prussians. If Ney believed he only had to sit and hold the Allies in position until the main army swept in from the East then surely the campaign would have been won and his inactivity would have been justified by the big picture.


The cavalry charges were an error of judgement, having been reprimanded for failure to act previously he may have been over compensating with haste. It is understandable to have thought the allied about face was the start of a retreat but to continue the attacks once the squares were well established is not so excusable.


He did have past form for such behaviour even before Russia, at Jena in 1806 it was Ney that could have cost the battle when he advanced out of his position to launch an attack on the Prussians, leaving a gap in the French lines and getting his own men surrounded and under a crossfire. His words at the time to his adjutant on realising they were against superior numbers were 'The wine is drawn; we must drink it!'

I think this is a great insight into Ney the man, was that his attitude to the 1815 campaign? He had maybe made a mistake but had made his bed and must now die in it?
A further sign of Ney perhaps knowing he had been promoted above his level of command was the battle of Dennewitz in 1813. Prior to Liepzig Napoleon planned a strike on Berlin that might knock Prussia out of the war. Ney was despatched to strike whilst Berlin's defenses were not so strong. He spent the entire first day reviewing his troops then marched north on a single road. He was blocked by a Prussian army with Russian reinforcements close by. The battle was brutal and almost a French victory but at the last some troops in the centre broke and fell back causing confusion and panic in those behind and suddenly victory turned to defeat and pursuit. The victory boosted allied confidence and when the King of Bavaria heard of it he abandoned the French alliance.
 A common criticism of Ney at Dennewitz was that he was in the front line amid the smoke and carnage and failed to know what was going on elsewhere on the field. A brave and admirable position for a colonel or junior general but not an army commander. 
According to Nafzinger Ney offered to resign saying 'I would rather serve as a grenadier than as a Marshal'.





In conclusion I sympathize with Ney, he was never a schemer like Soult or Bernadotte or a looter like Massena. He was a soldier's soldier down to his muddy boots and the troopers loved him for it. His leading of the rearguard out of Russia with a musket in hand and his strength of personality brought out the loyalty of his men and demonstrates all the best qualities that made Ney a legend as a man, if perhaps not a marshal, the bravery of a grenadier!

--------------------

45e in the great war.

Not a usual subject but with the centenary of the end of the first world war very soon upon us I thought I would include a couple of pictures of the 45e from that time. The first is a moment of repose from the western front in 1916 and the second taken in Salonika on the Greek front in 1917.




1914-1918. Never again.


-------------------------------------------------------------
Rogues gallery!



'I'm on a boat!'



Five go to Dover.

Young guns!

Went the day well?  er, no.

Having evicted Bill Odie French campaigners wonder whether having a shed is cheating.



As usual feel free to submit any news or articles. Anyone interested in doing some wargaming over the winter should join the 45eme wargamers page if your not already on it. May we all meet again on the field in 2019, adventure lies ahead!